Липецкая газета. 1996 г. (г. Липецк)

11 3 p e Aa K I I MO HHOM n0 4 Tbl 2 6 ceHTq6pw 1 9 9 6 r . H a A e ^ H b i i f A p y r ^ c o e e r m i K Ns 1 8 4 (1 2 4 8 ) H E M O r y M O H H A T b P o c c m n H H e p a s o 6 B H H t u j n a H p e a m e p H O H n o r i H T H a n p o B a H H o c T H . O b k t 3 t o t , k b k r o B O - p H T C B , H M e e r m b c t o 6 b i T b . C e r o a H B h h k o m y h b 6 e 3 p a 3 / i H H H O , n o H B M y c r p a n a y > K e h b - C K o n b K o n e r K p e a y K a T H T c a b n p o n a c T b , h , k c o T K a / i e H H i o , h b b h a h o C T p e M n e n n a b j i b c t h c n a c T H e e o r n o n n o r o K p a x a . H a w n c o r p a M A a n e y M e h b B e p a r h h b k b k h b C B B T / i b i e o 6 e - m a H H B M o S H a A B S K U B a t o m n e a a B e p e H n a . J U o / x H , c f i a B a B o r y , H a y n n n n c b c b m h o p e H n B a n n o n o x e n n e n A e n a r b n p a a n / i b H b i e B b iB O A b i . B e e H a u t e o h h H a e o A f i T H a M b i c A b : h t o x e o t o a a p e < p o p M b i , K O T o p b i e n e c y r e r p a n e p a a p y x y , n o r e p i o 6 b i n o a m o u x h h a B T o p m e r a , a 6 o n b W H H C T B y p o c c n a n — o 6 H H U t a - H H B H y H H X B H H B ? H H B C A y H a H H O S a x p a A b lB a B T C a M b I C A b O A p a B H A b H O C T H B b l 6 p a H H O r O K y p e a , r y M a H H O C T n n o c T a B A B H H o n u b a h . B O T o 6 3 T O M B O B H B U t B H H B U tB n H W y T B p B A a K l f H I O H B W H H H T a T B A H . BAH KPOTUYHACHBHPiAnPHSITHI, AnPABHTEJIbCTBOrOBUIBCTBO,BOCYflAPCTBO To, MTO CO CTpaHOfi TBOpHTCa HTO-TO HOBe- poBTHoe M f le ^ a N h N C i KpatiHe naoxn , Bps fl an KTO 3ApaB0MbicaRinnkt peujuTCfl ocnapuBaTb . DpaBMTeabCTBO no HHeppun nb iraeTca BceanTb B Mac Haflexcay Ha CKopyra cTa6 i/mn3aumo. Ho MO>KHO an 0 6 3T0M B 0 0 6 uj,e rOBOpMTb, KOPAa npoAoaxaeTCH paaaaa npon3BOACTBa, e rp an y aaAyiAnan rpnaanoHHb ie H e na a re xn , AecsTKn MnaanoHOB p o K K m ^ ! h o N i / " ^ s t h h aapnaa tb i, h h nencHH? OaKinnecKHM 5aHKpoTOM c ra a o po c - CHHCKoe npasHieabCTBO, a aa h h m h see ro c y - AapcTBO, He/HaxoAaiAee K p o ^ K t N A a x e na Bbi- na a ib i N o g h h u m N Hesne. CeroAHB yx<e He h 3 ^ o aaAaBaTbca Bonpo- COM, KTO AOBea POCCHKD AO T3K0r0 COCTOflHHq. 0TB6T xopoLuo H3BecTeH: npaBHTeabCTBO pe - cjjopMaTopoB. Kax BbiacHaeTcn, o h o K caM o ro Hanaaa « l u o k o N o h TepanHH» npe 6 biBaao N nae - Hy HaaKD3HH H He HMeao h 6 t k o h nporpaMMb i paayMHoro pe0opMHpoBaHHfl o 6 mecTBa. O h o noaa raao , h t o poccHPiCKyio SKOHOMHxy m o x h o H 3MeHHTb, TBK CKaaaTb, B OAHH OpHCeCT, H >KeC- TOKO npOCHHTaaOCb, Eme B 1992 roAy caMb iii "BbicoKHH® peefiop- Marop aaaBHa; N #$ npoBGAeM paarocyAapcTBae- HHe npeAnpHBTHH, h axoHOMHKa CAeaaex pw - BOK BnepeA. P < N #% npoHsoo iea , h o ... N o 6 p a r - HOM HanpaBaeHHH. B 19 93 -95 roAax 6 biao xo- POUJO BHAHO, HTO B MBCCOBOM MaCLUTa 6 e HAOT OCTBHOBKa npeAnpHBTHH. nOHGMy 6 bl npH 3TOM Ha noabay A say He aaAencTBOBaTb He ToabKO pbIHOHHbie pblHarn, h o H aAMHHHCTpaTHBHbie? CKaX<eM, BpeMeHHO BBOCTH CflHKCHpOBaHHbie ueHbi Ha SHeproHocHTeaH, nepeBoaxy rpyaoB no xeaeaHOH A op o re . 3 t o Aaao 6 w nponaBOAHxe- asM nepeAbiLuxy, BoaMOXHOCTb naxonHTb 0 6 0 - poTHbie cpeACTBa, paasHTb Aeao. Ho N npaBH- TeabCTBe, N h ^ h m o , nocHHTaan, h t o h o m 6 oabUje paaopflKJTca npeAnpHRTHB, t g m paAHxaabHee pe- cfiopMbi. OHeBHAHbl npOCHeTbl B 4)HHaHCOBOH ccfiepe. H 3 Aecb He npeAnpHHBTO AencTBeHHbix Mep Aaa Toro , HTo 6 bi xaany nonoaHHTb ecxecTBeHHbiM o 6 paaoM aa K ! g t naaoroB , a He nyreM h h t 6 h K h - 0HxauHH pa 6 oTbi nenaTHoro CTanxa. PocyAapcTBO cfiaxTHHecxH ne Hcnoabayex CBoero MOHonoabHoro npaea na nponaBOACTBO H peaaHaauHKj cnnpTHbix nannTxoB. Koab ceroA- HB cnnpTHoe A o c ryn no NK &' h NK N , t o nonetuiy 6 bi rocyAapcTBy He naBaenb na axo ro sbiroAy, coSnpaB paayMHbie naao rn , axunaw , nou jann u Ha BBoa? Paapemena 6 biaa AeaxeabHoexb Hananaab- Ho MoiiieHHHHecxHX xoMnaHHH THna “ MMM», "PyeexHH AOM cea en ra x , oPyeexaa HeABH>xH- MOCTb» H ApyrHX. PoccHBHe BaaoM Hecan xyAa AeHbTH, o 6 MaHyxbie apxoH pexaaMoCi. Ho h aAocb TOcyAapcTBO npeHe 6 pe rao cpeACTBawH naceae- HHB H OTAaaO HX B pyXH XynXH MOUjeHHHXOB. PaaBe axo ne noxaaaxeab h K $ h h h o t o anpa na- lAHX aHAepoB? CaoBOM, BonpocoB m h o t o , h o OTBexoB Hex. HanpaiAHBaexcB N n N o ^ : ! N l u h pyxoBOAHxeaH AGHCTByKax He c no3HUHH aApaso ro CMbicaa, a N yroA y SanaAy. C N #! BbiBOA CAeaaa h N . HanpHwep, ecan 6 bi oxenecTBeHHbie npeAnpHBXHB pa 6 oxaaH x o t N 6 bi Ha 70 npoAGHTOB m o i ^ h o K t h , t o Haw 6 bi He noHaAoOnaHCb xpeAHXbi aanaAHbix HHBeexopoB, 6 biaO 6 bl AOCXaXOHHO C 0 6 cXBeHHblX HHSeCTHUHH. H . r A J I K H H . r . J lnneAK . AJIKOrOJIHSMBPOCMM3AMBTHOnOMOJIOfliJI XoHy xocHyxbCB nexb ipex Ba>xHbix mo mg h t o N H aLueii > x h 3 h h . riepBbiH. npaBHTeabCTBO He paa «panopxo- Baao» HapoAy 0 6 ycneiuHOM aaeepujeHHH nep - Bbix axanoB npHBaxHaauHH rocnpeAnpHBXHH. H t o > xe npHHecan o h h expane, poccHBHaw? Hnne ro , xpoMe paaBaaa, rp a 6 e>xa rocyAapcTBennoH co - 6 cTBeHHOCTH, o 6 oraiAeHHB He 6 oabiAOH xynxn «npHXBaTH3axopoB». CaoBOM, h t o t n p o p e c c a paarocyAapcTsaeHHB nenaaen h ouenxa etny na- BecTHa. Ho xxo o t N # t h t napoAy aa axH ^ o h K t - BHB? fla>xe raaBHbiH npHBaxHaaxop Hy 6 anc , na speMB HarnaHHbiH c oanMna BaaexH, N h o NN , xax roBopHTCB, Ha xoHe, aaHHMaex BaxHenujHH noex npH npeaHAGHTe. HaAO noaa raxb , h t o npeACXo- HT caeAyx)LAHH axan npHBaTHaapHH, xoTopwH h aaBepiAHT paaeaa h paarpaOaeHHe cxpanb i. BxopoH . MaaecTHO, h t o expany aaAyLunan BceoOiAHe Henaaxe>XH. Mnaanonb i aKDASH expa- AaxiT OT HeBbiAaHH aapnaaxbi, nencHH. Ho 0 6 - aacTH A o a r no h h m coexaBaBex ^ o K N t x h MHa- anapAOB pyOaen. MaBeexHO neMaao caynaes, xoxAa Bbinaaxbi aaAepxHBaancb npeAnaMepen - Ho. ByAb y Hac N o 6 aacxn xoHxpoaHpyxjiAHH axn Bonpocbi opraH , xaxo ro 6 bi ne np onao iiiao . C h h - xaKD, HTO aaAana anxBHAauHH A oa ra no aapnaa - xe H nencHBM Aoa>xHa 6 bixb pe iaena nepaon . Mnane ntopyi npocxo nepeexanyx pa 6 oxaxb, ^ o - BepBXb BaacxH, HcnoaHBXb aaxoHW. TpexHH. Hauue o O " ^ # K $ N # y cnaenno 6 opex- CB c paaryaoM npeexynHoexH. BpBAan axy 6 opb- 6 y MO)KHO npHanaxb ycneiuHOH. n o aa ra io , Aeao 3AeCb B TOM, HTO MbI HeAOOUeHHBaeM BaHBHHe Ha npecryoHOCTb 6 eapa 6 oxHUbi. MaaeexHO, h x o neaoBex, anujeHHbiH cpeACXB ^ NN cyiAecxBOBa- HHB, noHAex Ha Bce, h t o O n Bb ixnxb. K ObiaoMy aaxoHy o BceoOiAeH aaHBxocxH Boaepaxa 6 bixb He Mo>xex, HO xoHxpoab aa BbicBo 6 o>XAeHHeM xpyAOcnocoOHoro HaceaeHHB Aoaxcen 6 bixb x e c - xHe. Jlx)AeH, He HMeo iAnx o o K (# N !!#! paOoxbi, HaAO ujHpe npHBaexaxb x onaanneaeMOMy 0 6 - LuecxBeHHO noaeanoMy xpyAy. ToxAa y OoabLUHH- cxBa He OyAex Hy>xAbi h BpeMenn coBepmaxb npaBOHapyujeHHB. H HexBepxbiH. CHHxara, nopa noBeexn pe iiiH - xeabHoe H ac rynaenne na n p ou e c c cnaHBanHB Hau,HH. CeroAHB cnnpxHoe Aoexynno NK & m h xa>x- AOMy. nbBHbiH Ha yaHLi,e, N xpaHcnopxe Boenpn- HHMaexcB xax HopMa. Bce na iue BcxpeHamcB 13-14-aexHHe peOBxa N nbBHOM N h ^ g . Rbiox h AGB yiaxH. PoccHHcxHH aaxoxoaH3M aaMexHO no- MoaoAea h N g ^ N t x paaBaay ceMen, HpaBCXBen- HoexH, HHxeaaexxa. A . y B A P O B . r . J iHneAK . JIHUIMJIHnOCJIBflHBHHAMBJKAb! M h g 83 roAa , N — HHBaaHA c 5oabUJHM exa- >xeM. f le a roAa naaaA CAaaa ASHbrn N xoMoa- HHK3 «PyccxHH AOM ceaeHxa». PaccHHXbmaaa noAxonnxb na noxopoHW, Aa N o x ocxaaacb h h K HGM. ><PflC» aonnya , xax MwabHUH nyawpb, h K - nea na noaB apeHHB. MnaanapAb i cpeACXB po c - CHBH ocxaaHCb N xapManax mo l u g h h h x o N . K K o - >xaaeHHK3, rocyAapcxBO , N CBOe N p g m N aaxpwB- Luee raaaa na AeBxeabHocxb NN ! o neaaxoHHbix xaMnaHHH, K h N ^ o K K & 6 N NK k i oxaexcxBeHHOCXb aa BoaapaiAeHHe cpeACXB acAHM. Ho coBexy KDpncxa B noAaaa na -iPflCo N cyA, h o y>xe roA Hex HHxaxoro oxsexa. Ha x o ro >xe HaAeBXbCB h t ^ N Hcxaxb onopy? M g h N h mh o x h x APyrnx aHiuHan A a x e cpeACxs, oxao)xeHHbix na HepHbiCi ^ s h N . Tenepb mw h g xoabxo He m o x g m HopMaabHO >XHXb, h o h no - aKDACXH ynxH na xox K N &( . E . C M O J I b H H H H O B A . r . J iH neAK . • 0 6 s o p nMcejvi m i W h EE3 nPMKPAC P e r y aB p H O HMxaB p eA axAHO HH y io n o H x y , MHOXAa m o > " - Ho BH o aH e o 6 xoAHXbCB 6 e a HH (|)opMaAMOHHb ix n p o r p a M M paAHO M x e a eB H A eH H B , c e p b e a H b ix r a a e x H b ix c x a x e H . M 6 0 B RHC bM a x H M x a x e a e i i « / i r » e e x b B c e , 7 x o x a p a K x e p H a y e x c e roAHBU JH io io C H x y a uH io 4 o 6 a a c x H 7 A ax<e 4 P o F F 7 7 : }KH3Hb 6 e a n p H x p a c . E o a e e x o r o , n o 7 7 m , x a x n o H a p o - AHb iM n p H M e x a M , m o > x 7 o B n o a n e n p o x H o a n p o B a T b p a sBM - XHe c o A H a a b H b ix n p o A e c c o B . Box, x a a a a o c b 6 b i, HCCB xaex noxox E exceH ueB 7 3 7 3 - AHOH aabH b ix o x p aH H 6 biBLue ro CCCP, 7 o , cyAB no n n c b - M 3 M , Ha O H ep eAH 7 o 4 4 4 B o a n a — yxee c c e a e p H b ix p a n - OHOB P o F F 7 7 , D p H M o p b B , K aM s a xK H . r ie n a a b H O t o , 7 t o c xp eM B TC n y e x a x b o r r y A a He r o a b x o ncHCHO H e pb i , a x iA H o x p a 6 oxaBU JH e , 7 o 7 M o a o A b te B b ic o x o x a a c c H b ie c n e u n a - a n c T b i n o a a e x x p o H H x e , HH Jxenepb i, c x p o H x e a H , y n H x e n B . □ o -n p e x c H e M y o c x p b i c o A H a a b H b ie n p o 6 a e M b i 7 x e x , xxo y x (e n o 6 b iB a a 4 p o a n n e p e c e a e H A a n a n 6 ex ceHA a . Ox, x a x H e a e r x o npHXCHXbcn n a 7 o 4 o m M e e x e 7 m , n o x ep nB u iHM n p n - BbiHHyx ) c p e A y o E 7 t 4 7 7 4 , ycTOHHHBbiH x p y x A P y a e i i , 3 H a - XOMblX H A ax<e pOACXBeHHHXOB. Box nHCbMO H3 T y p X M 6 HHH: «K 3p a , CbIHOX, OTXaHXHHCb! Te6n 7 { G F t m 4 m o . M o 7 a A p e c npexcHHH : y p re H H » . 3 x 0 Hanncaaa m 4 m 4 K> p 7 4 KaoHXOBa, npoxcHsaBUjero AO AGxa 6 pn 1 9 9 5 roAa 4 o G 7 o m 7 3 paiiOHOB Haujen 0 6 - aacTH. BoceMb MecnAea naaaA o 7 F o o E G ^ 7 G , 7 t o nep ee a - x(aex B coceAHHH panoH, 7 F xex nop Hex ox Hero Beexeii. PacnaA orpoMHoro rocyAapexaa nanec ypoH He xoabxo axo- HOMHxe, HO H HeaoBenecxHM Ayu iaM ... A xb i lO p H H , e c a n n p o H x e u jb 3 x 7 e x p o x n , B c e >xe n a n n - u iH M a x e p H , y c n o x o H e e . A p y r o H xeMOH xpeBOxcHbix n n c e M c x a a o n o a o x c e n n e n e n cH O H e p oB 7 n p e e x a p e a b i x rp a x cA a n . C x aB A ja n yxce x p o - H HH e c x oH 3 B A ^ x < x a neHCHOHH o ro n o c o 6 HB A a n M H o rn x 3H aH H x e a b H o o o o e x p H a a n p o 6 a e M b i BbixcHBaHHB. C xapH XH yxce n p o c x o n e 3Hax>x , n a 7 o m mo x F 7 o ca xoHOM HX b , 7 n o - p o H B e n n e o x » x a 6 y» Bxax>HaexcB n o A n n e x a n a r a a e x b i 7 xc ypH a a b i . B H H c a o x a xH X n o n a A e x , 4 7 G 7 m o , 7 7 4 G ‘ n o e x o - BHHbiH H H x a x e a b , n e n cH O H e p 7 3 c e a a K p y x b ie X y x o p a J I 7 - n e A x o r o p a i io H a B a a e n x H H (P eA o poBHH H e p H b iu io B , n a n n - caBAJHH HaM n p o c e a b c x o e x cH a b e -S b ixb e : "PaAHO B HBAJeM ce a e He pa 6 oxaex yxce ceMb Mecn- A 6 B, a x a e 6 npHsosBx xaxoH, 7 x o xceeaxb e ro Moryx xoab ­ xo axiAH c xceaeaHbiMH 3y6aMH». D o x o m 4 nncbMe c a e A y - K3X BOnpOCbl, Ha xoxopbie OH He B COCXOBHHH HBHXH Bpa3y- MHxeabHbiH oxBex. (loHeMy 4 ceabcxHX Maraannax npo- Ayxxbi HaMHoro Aopoxce, 7 4 m 4 ropoAe , a naaxa aa raao - Boe oxonaeHHe OAHHaxoBa H 3 7 m o 7 7 aexoM? A a 7 F ae - MeabHbix naeB nencHOHepbi HHHero He noaynax jx . r io n e - My? "BeAb rpa6nx , — CHHxaex o 7 , — cxapnxoB G o xnocaeA - Hen xanaH xpoBH». K c x a x H , B c x o p e B a a e n x H H a cp eA opoBHH a o r p a E n a n 7 4 npBMOM C M b ic a e a x o r o c a o B a — HOHbXj c a e a n c o A a o p a x o p o s y , A a H y F o F 4 G F 7 xoxce . V m 7 G 7 G 7 7 , x a x n a r p e x , 6 e H 3 H H a He o x a a a a o c b . C n a c n E o n p e A c e A a x e a x ) M e e x H o - r o TOO 3 A y a p A y / l a p H H y , x o x o p b iH n a CB oeM « y a aH x e » B M e e x e c n o x e p n e B A iH M H H eM eA a eH H O o x n p aB H a c s i n a n o - HCXH. H a m a n c x o xH H x y 4 1 5 x n a o M e x p a x o x c e a a . B o p b i xce c x p b iaH C b . "S n aH H X , M H p H e 6 e a A o 6 p b ix a x iA e n h ) — x a x neoxcH - AaHHO a a x oH H H a c B o e nHCbMO n e n c H O H e p . A B eA b 3 X 0 xoxce oAH a n a r a aB H b ix x e M n n c e M 7 4 G ‘ 7 x HH x a x e a e H . « }KH x eH c xH e a a 6 o x b i , n o aH X H H e c x n e A H C x y c c n n , c o 6 bi- XHR B H e n n e , xpyAHOCXH 4 x o 7 o m 7 " 7 H e AOaxcHbi a a x M e - B axb A n n H a c ny xxHX 7 S e c x o p b ic x H b ix a x >A eH , M a c x e p o B 7 n p o c | )e c cH O H a a oB C B o e ro A e a a » , — CHH xae x H am a H H xa - x e a b H H A a n a E a b A a EB reHHB H n x o a a e B H a K o n a e e a . C a y - H H a a c b 6 e A a . E e m ^ 4 noH xn B ean aA excHOM F o F x o 4 7 7 7 6 b ia A o e x a e a e H 4 o 6 aa c xH y x > 6oabHHAy, 7 o 6 p n r a A a p e a - HHM aAHOHHO ro o xA e a eH H B 4 o r a a e e c B n x x o p o M E a p a n o - BbiM c n a c a a e r o . «M 3 x o nyAO , — n n m e x E. K o n a e e a , — c x a a o B03M0XCH0 6 a a r o A a p n H e x o a b x o M a c x e p c x e y e p a n a H e r o x o a a e r , 7 o 7 7 x 7 7 F x o n e a o B e n e c x H M x a n e e x s a M — ox ab iBHHBO cxH , A o 6 p o x e , yM eH H io y x p e n n x b 4 6 oabHOM B e p y B XCH3Hb». B H H M a x e a b H o e , c o H y e e x e e n H o e o x H o m e n n e x a x iA HM H eo E x oA HM O H e x o a b x o 4 a x e x p eM a a b H O H C H xyaAHH , 7 o 7 B 0 6 blHH 0 H HB A len , XOXB H OHBHb HenpOCXOH , XCH3HH. Y 4 B- p e H , x o rA a MOH bm e 6 y A e x n o e x y n a x b 4 p e A a x A H io x p e e o x c - Hbix n n c e M , a 6 o a b m e 6 y A e x x a x n x , x a x o e H a n n c a a a K a a e - AHB B a c n a b e e n a C M a r n n a n a J ln n e A K a . T p n rOA a o n a yxce He p a 6 o x a e x n a CBOeM poAHOM n p e A - npHBXHH AO "> K e a e 3 o 6 e x o H » , 7 o F o 4 F F m He H y e e x e y e x c e 6 n OAHHOXOH, xo xB x p yA H O c x eH B XCH3HH X B a x a e x . M x c a n x - BOH n e p e x p b i e a e x B H H M a x e a b H o e n H y x x o e o x H o m e n n e x B e x e p a n a M n a a x oM n p e A n p n n x H H . 3 p , e c b 7 m , n e 4 n p n - M e p A P y rH M , BCeXAa B o e p eM B B b in a a n n e a io x AHBHAeHAb i, 0 C 0 6 0 HyxcAaK}A{HMCB o x a a b iB a x jx M a x e p n a a b H yK ) noMOA^b, n p e A a a r a x > x o x A o x n y x b B a a e o A c x o M G o m 4 o x A b ix a . B c e r - A a no aA p aB BX n e p e a M H o ro xn p a x cH y io r a a e x y c lo S H a e e M , n p n r a a c n x n a np aaAHHHH b in e e n e p . . . M 7 o x o a n B e x e p a n y HaAO , x o rA a o 7 a n a e x , 7 x o o 7 o m n oM H n x n a a B o x n x c n ? " A a a a n x e He a a 6 b iBaxb o x o p o m n x a x JA a x , c x a p a io A tn x - c n HaM noMOHb» , — x a xHM o E p a A ie n n e M a a e e p m n a a F 4 o 7 p a c c x a a K a aB A n n B a c n a b e e n a . B peAaxAHOHHOH n o H x e H B M a a o n n c e M n n a A p y r n e x e M b i H a m e n xen an n : n p a A o e x H u e , n c y r y 6 o A o a o B b ie , n xp eB o x cH b ie , n n e n a a b H u e . )KH 3H b n p o A o a x c a e x c e . . . A H a x o j i H H I I I A X O B , p e n a K T o p O T A e a a nHce iv t « J i r » . • C noBO noAnMCHMKy ccimnEUKyio t a s e t y x Bb in i icu BAio nOTOMY, MTO... no T e pa xb « J i r » flJ ifl Mena — T pa re a n a . K saM , McypnajiHCTbi, y Mena eexb npocbSa; ne- HaxaHTe x o t N paa N ^ N 6 nefleJiH lOMopHcrane- CKHe paccKaabi, aneKflOTbi, a t o N & ^ N K # NK g m paayHHjiHCb ne t o ^ N k o CMearbca, h o h y a b i- 6 aTBca. E . K y 3 H E I i ; 0 B A . r . J ln n e pK . . . .c o 6 aacTHOH raaeTo ii CBaaaHa naMHTB o pOAHOM H 0AH3KOM MH 6 HeAOBeKe, MyjKe Ba- CHAHH HBanOBHHe, CTaXBH KOTOpOrO B new nySAHKOBBAHCb. O h BcerAa xenao oxabiBaaca o coxpyAHHKax raaexBi, noAAepJKHBaa c h h m h A o 6 pb ie oxHomeHHH. Tenepb e ro Hex. H o oexa- Aacb y MeHH «JlHnenKaH raaexa» , K o x o p yw a He M o ry He Bb inncB iBaxb. B. 4 > E f l0 C 0 B A . r . J ln n e i iK . ...OHa c 1954 roAa cxaaa m o h m nocxoHH- HblM HaAeJKHbIM APYXOM H COBeXHHKOM. M h 6 HpaBHXca yMHb ie, oCcxoflxeABHBie MaxepHaAW o ropoAe. ra a e x y A io 6 ax h m o h BpaxbH, k o x o - 11 bie HCHByx B BopoHence h J(HenponexpoBCKe . 'pnea jKaH k o m h g , aaHHXBiBawxcH era h y s o - 3HX aK3eMnAspb i c C 0 6 0 H. H eme. H c yAO- BOAbcxBHeM yHacxByK) B B an ie i i n rp e — xaK npHHXHO HCAaxb H HaAeaxbCH Ha h x o - x o x op o - uiee . r . JlHnen,K A . y X K H H A . ...MHe HpaBHXCH MaxepHaAbi xeMaxHHecKHX cxpaHHA, «OHar», «J(aHHHKH». BoA bm oe cna - K h 6 o 3KypH2iAHCxaM 3a nySAHKauHH paccKa- 30B o HameM Kpae, e ro HcxopHH. B . K O H E B B IX . r . J ln n e uK . ...OHa Hecex mh g AoexosepHyra h noAny ra HHCfjOpMaUHIO 0 COBpeMGHHOH 3KH3HH. f l — HHBaAHA, H raaexy mh g HHxarax poAcxseHHH- KH. « J i r » — axo Haexoamaa rasexa . c. HaMaAKOBO. A . H E M H C O B . • H M T a r e j i b n p e A ^ c i r c i e T OB1>5I BJI EHMil - HE MYCOt> HacxHbie oS iaBAGHHH... J le n a x h x ro p o - Hcane t ^ g nonaAO, He saAyMbiBaacb o x o m , h x o X blCHHH SyMaXCeK, AOXMOXbHMH BHCHmHG Ha cJjoHapHbix exoASax, cxenax ^ o m o N , BH xpnnax MarasHHOB, aacoparax ropoA , n o p x a x e ro 0 6 - AHK. Onb ix 6opb5b i ropoACKHX BAaoxeii c a x o i i Hanacxbra noKaaaa , h x o aanpexHxeABHBie Mepw He Aarax HHKaKoro atl)(J)eKxa. I Io a xoM y Ha oc- xaHOBKax o 6 mecxBeHHoro xpaH cnopxa noaBH- AHCb He5oAbnme cxeHABi AAa HacxHBix 061 = 513 - AGHHH. OAHaKO H 3X0X0 HGAOCXaXOHHO. E K ^ h B3axbca .3a n e j io c yMOM, n a u i ropoA M o r 6 bi cxaxb He x o ^ N k o n am e , h o h Sorane . BeAb HGM SoAbuie SyAGX «peaAH30BaH0'> 061 , - HBAeHHH, a 3HaHHX, COBGpnieHO CA 6 A 0 K HO npoAaace h oSMeny h g ^ N h ^ K h mo K x h , xpaH cnop - XHblX cpeACXB H X.A., X 6 M 6 oAbme AGHer (ox paOAHHHblX nOUIAHH H HBAOrOB) nOCXyHHX B ropoACKyra Kaany. Kaacexca, ropaaAo pa nbu ie Hac nonaAH axo B K # K & ^ h g m BopoHeacG, $ ^ & N caMOM neHxpe ropoAa paaMemeH orpoMHHH , ^ ^ h h o h MexpoB na xb -m e cxb , K (&! ^ A ^ h o 6 x>aBAeHHH. «H apo - AHaa xpona» k h g m y h g aapacxaex. T a n , m o - acex 6 b ixb , h HaM, AHnnanaM , noAo 6 HbiH K (&! ^ ( h ^ h cxeHAbi) B AK)AHbix MGCxax xopoAa MOr- AH 6 bi npHroAHXbca? H . B O J IA B IP E B . r . J ln n e i iK . HMMCHMM HAPK: KTO B HEM X035H1H? XoXeAOCb 6 bl nOAGAHXbCa CBOHMH Ha5AIO- AGHHAMH, CAGAaHHbIMH B H h JKHGM napKG S H n e i iK a . K coacaAGHHra, axo xpaAHi;HOHHoe Meexo oxAb ixa ropoacaH Bce 6 oAbme n p n x o - AHX B aanycxGHHe h ynaAOK. E K ^ h npoH xncb no aAAeaM h npnrAaAGXbca k ^ g p K NN ^ m , pac- xymHM 3Aecb, aaMenaemb, h x o mh o x h g h 3 h h x H a xpeXb HAH Aaace HanoAOBHHy NN i K o x ^ h . C yxH e BexKH noHGMy-xo ne o6pe3a raxca , h yMH pa ram ne AGpeBba npeACxaBAarax K o 6 o h HcaAKoe 3peAHmG. HaBHO He HHmeHHbie KanaBbi ^ ^ h exoKa BOAbi « 6 A a royxa rax» S o ^ o x h w m aanaxoM . B acapKyra no roAY s ^ g K N — HacxoamHH nnxoM - HHK AAa KOMapOB. Ox nGHCHOHepOB, ryAHIO- mHX B H h HCHGM, HaCTO CAblUiHUIb CeXOBaHHA Ha HeAOCxaxoHHoe k o ^ h h 6 K x N o CKaMeeK ^ ^ h oxAb ixa . HoneM y , yAHBAaAHCb m o h coSeceA- HHKH, HaxAyxo aaKpb ixb i ^ N g p h A s y x y raxHw x naBHAbOHOB, H axoAamH xca N # N ^ & h K x o h h h k ^ MHHepaAbHoii BOAbi? BeAb noA h x K p h im e i i cxapHKaM MoacHO S w ^ o 6 bi Kopoxaxb BpeMa 3a uiaxMaxaMH h ^ h ^ o m h h o . J (p y ra a K a xe ropna nocxoaHHWx nocexHxe- A e i i napKa — ^ g x h . KoxAa-xo h m na paAoexb N H nacHeM Bbipoc ropoAOK c AepGBaHHbiM fe - peMKOM, peSHblMH CKaMGHKaMH, (JlHrypKaMH CKaaoHHbix nepcoHaaceii. C x o h x o h h no c e i l A 6 Hb, ^ 3 xoAbKO He Bbi3biBaex npeacHGH pa - AOeXH HH y MaAblLUGH, HH y B3pOCAbIX. C k B- MGHKH noKOCHAHCb, AAK Ha cJ)HrypKax o 6 ^ y - nHAca. HyaceH 5b i peMOHX, h o y aAMHHHCxpa- HHH napKa pyKH ^ # Hero noneM y -xo He ^ o x o - Aax. B oxcyxcxBHG cpeACXB, neexHO roB o pa , He BepHxca. BeAb AGHCXByrox ace N napae axxpaK - HHOHbi, neHbi Ha Koxopb ie BecbMa NN i K o k h . lioH eM y 6 bi He noxpaxHXb Hacxb axHX Aene r Ha npHBeAGHHe H n a c n e ro N nopaAOK? H . C E PO B A . r . J ln n e p K . , • 3aKOH ecT b s q k o h (H a Bonpocb i MHTare iieM OTeenaeT lopucT J I m G m 7 E A M E Y P O B A ) TAE MOM EECHAATHblM AABOKAT? J J e a n e c s i i t a n a s a d o m K p b u io c b n a c n e d - c m e o M o e u 6 a 6 y u i K u . P o d e m e e n n u K u He x o m x m p a s p e m u m h c n o p n o c o z j i a c u w u o 6 p a m u n u c h e c y d . H u n e a j i u d 2 - u z p y n n b i . He p a d o m a H ) , M n e n y x e n a d e o K a m , o d n a KO 6 K p u d u n e c K O u K O H c y j ih m a v ,H u e C e e n n a m - H o u n oM o iU fU M H e o m K a a a j i u . P a s 'b i iC H u m e , M o z y J iu R n o j i y H u m b 6 e c n j i a m H y t o m p u d u - H e c K y jo n o M o u t b ? E e n u H e m , m o x m o u s z p a x e d u H u M e e m n a s m o n p a e o u e k u k u x c n yH U R X ? B. CKO KO B . r . J lH nepK . K coacaAGHHio, 3BK0 h , Koxopb iH 6 bi p e ry - AHpoBaA nopaAOK, ycAOBHa, cJjopMbi OKaaaHHa 6 ecnAaxH 0 H rapHAHHecKoft noMomw no rpaac- AaHCKOMy np op e c c y , ^ # H aexoam e ro BpeMenn HG npHHax . HecMOxpa na axo , SGcnAaxHyra rapHAHHecKyra noM om b OKaabiBarax k o ^ ^ g x h h aABOKaxoB, h o no BecbMa orpanHHeHHOMy ne- PGHHK), a HMGHHO: — O B3HCKaHHH aAHMeHXOB; — O B03MemeHHH BpeAa, npHHHHGHHOrO yBGHbeM, CBaaaHHbiM c paSoxo ii; — O B03MGmGHHH BpeAa, npHHHHGHHOrO CMepXbK) KOpMHAbU,a; — no xpyAOBbiM cnopaM (cx . 22 IIoAoaceHHa o5 aABOKaxype PC<I>QP ox 1980 r . ) . K aK BHAHO H3 yKaaaHHOro ne pe an a . Bam cyAG 6 HbiH cno p ne oxHOCHXca k pasSHpaxeAb- CXBV ASHHOH KaxerOpHH AGA. H o Bce ace peKOMeHAVGM o 6 paxHXbca N rapHAHHecKyra KOHcyAbxauH io, ( ^ g , h K x o ^ h h 3 Bame ro MaxepHaAbHoro noAoaceHHa h no B3a- HMHOMy co rAam eHH io c aABOKaxoM, CMoacexe peuiHXb Bonpoc onAaxb i e ro roH opapa . • f l o e n y X O M M O B T O p i l T e T H O CJI OBO - CEPEEPO , MOJI HAHM E - 3 0 JI 0 T 0 I J p a e d a n u , n m o C K o p o e J I u n e i ^ K e 6 y d e m e e e d e n a n o - e p e n e H H a R o n n a m a s a n o R b s o e a H u e n a o M a u i H U M m e n e - A . B E J IO y C O B A . ^O H O M ? — I Ip aB A a , — oxBexHA na Bonpoc H a n ie i i HHxaxeAbH jmb i B HHXepBbK) KOppeCnOHAGHXy « J i r » AHPGKTOp JlHnG IlKOH XO- p o A C K o i i T e a e ^ o H H O H c x a H i iH U H 4 ' 7 P a p K y m H H . — C 7 F t : - Ma BAGKxpoHHoro noACHGxa paaroBopoB aOoHeHxoB Hannex ^ g h - cxBOBaxb B J lHneuKG yace N CAGAyrameM roAY , KOXAa 3apa6o-, xarax HecKOAbKO h w h g c x p o am u x c a aAGKxpoHHbix A T C . Cne- unaAbHoe oSopyAOBaHne 5yAGx yHHXb iaaxb noMHHyxHO N p g m h paa roBopa KaacAoro a 6 oHGHxa h , cooxaexcxBeHHo, HaHHCAaxb HAaxy. — H n a H A A e K c e e B H M , 7 : n o A y n H X c a G 7 t ' " , 7 t o G " > G 7 , 3 KOHOMH CBOH AGHbXH, pG3KO COKpETHT xeAe(|)OHHbie p a 3 r0 - B opb i? H aKOHOMHMecKHH a^(J)eKT OT HOBOBBeAeHHH n o n - pOCTy CHGAGTCa K B y j lK ? — O n w x p a 6 oxb i axoH cHCTeMw N A P y r n x rop oA a x noKa - 3 aA, HXO nnaxeacH aa noAbsoBaHne xeae^OHOM nepBoe BpeMa AGHCXBHXGAbHO naABKIX. OAHaKO BnOCAGACXBHH OHH HaHHHa- rax pacxH — AHDAH npHBb iKarax k noapeMennoH onAaxe . — ByAGT AH coxpaHGHa o 6 biMHaa aSoHeHTCKaa n n a x a aa TGAecJlOH? — Ona HG xoAbKO coxpaHHXca, h o h oyAex yBGAHHHBaxb- ca . B KaKOH npo rpeccHH — cpnaac CKasaxb xpyAHO. B K &! - x a 6 pe , HanpHMep , aOoHGHxaM npHAGxca nAaxHXb aa noAbso- BaHHG xeAe5)0H0M Ha ^ N g xbicHHH 6 oAbme . 9 x o CBaaaHO c no - BbimeHHeM x a p n ^ o B Ha aAeKxpoaHeprn ra , Koxopoe np oH sou i- AO B HanaAG Mecaua . ^ A a cBaancxoB — cepbeanwH yAap , N & ^ N PTC no xpe 6 Aarax orpoMHoe k o ^ h h g K x N o aAGKxpoaHeprHH. K coAcaAGHHra, Han iH aKOHOMnnecKne xpyAHOCxn pHKomexoM 6 bK)x n o KapManaM aSoHGHxoB. — T g m He Menee uoBb ie xeAe4)OHHbie cxaH iiHH 4 rop oA e cxpoHTca . O xKyAa ace 6 e p y x c a a e n b r n ? — B h ^ h m o , penb h ^ g x o c x aH ^H a x , cxpoHxeAbcxBo k o x o - p b ix BGAGXca Ha cpGACXBa HacGAGHHa. M b I rapaHXHpyGM rpaac- AanaM ycxaHOBKy xGAetlioHa N xeneHHe roAa . CyMMa xeAecJioH- Ho ro a a nm a — 2 ,5 MHAAHOHa pyOAGH. K c xa xH , rpaacAanaM , Koxopw e He CMoryx N ! K K x h NK k ) cyM - My epasy , npeAoexaBAGHa BOSMOJKHOcxb cAGAaxb axo naexaMH — B Asa axana . CKaacy npaMO, csasHCxaM axo HGBwroAHO, HHCbAHUHa n o n p o e x y «c’beAaex» Hacxb noAyneHHM x xaKHM o 6 pa 3 0 M cpeACXB. H o m N i h ^ g m na xaKOH m a r , ynHXb iBaa h h - xepecb i MaAOoeecnGHGHHbix rpaacAan h neHCHonepoB. HHTepBbH) B3HA l O p H M , 5 b J I K O B . 3 A 0 4 H 0 E P E L U E H M E C Y A A i M O ^ H O 0 E > K A J 1 0 B A T b | B e p n y B W H C b h 3 x o M B H A n p o B K H , SI n o A y H H A n a c b o h b a - I p e c a a o H H o e p e w e n n e c y / j a . P a a b s t e n m e , H M B A a a h n p a a o I C y A b B B b IH O C H T b B M O B O T C y T C T B H B a a O H H O B p B W e H H B H HTO I H B O S X O A H M O M H B n p B A n p H H S I T b , H T o 6 b l B TO H 3 M B H H T b ? | B . TOHKMX . I r . JlnneuK. | HeHCTBHTGAbHO, B COOTBeXCTBHH C H3MeHeHHBMH B rpa>KAaH- | CKO-npopeccyaAbHOM KOAGKce PCcPCP, BBGAeHHbiMn B flencTBHe I c 9 BHBapa 1996 r., HapoAHbin cyAbfi HMeer npaao BbiHecxn aaon- I Hoe peoieHHe, eenn pacnona raex cBeAeHHHMH o t o m , mt o o iB ex - | HHK 6 bm HaAne>KamHM o6pa30M H3BemeH o Meexe h BpeMGHH cy - | Ae 6 Horo aaceAaHHB, OAHaKO N cyA h g asHnea. f ln a BbmeceHHa | aaoHHoro pemeHHa xpeOyexca co rnacHe h APyrOH cxopoHbi — h K - I xpa. I E K ^ h N w He comacHW c saoaHWM peineHneM cyAa, M o xe re | o6>KanoBaxb ero , Hanneas saaeneHne o nepecMoxpe pemeHHa N | TeaeHHe 15 ^ h 6 h nocne e ro sbiHeceHHa. B h g m npHBOAHtca ne - i peHGHb o 6 cxoaxenbCTB, noMeiiiaBLUHx saM aBHXbca Ha cyAe 6 Hoe 1 saceAaHHe, c AOKasarexibCTBaMH xo ro , h t o N u HaxoAHAHCb N axo \ BpeMa B KOMaHAHpoBKe. flaHHoe aaaBneHHe rocnom/iHHOH ne 0 6 - * naraexca h npeAOCiaBnaexca N cyA no HHcny ^ h u , yHacxsyramHX N ; AGAG. 1 « E C J 1 M E C T b 3 A A O J 1 ) K E H H O C T b I n o A J 1 l i M E H T A M » M o p o r a a p e A a x U H S i , n p o w y p a a b s t C H H T b , k b k h m o B p a a o M SI M o r y n o A y H H T b a A H M B H T b i o r 6 b i B w e r o u y x a n a A O H b f l e - CS ITH A B T H a O C H O B B H H H p B W B H H S I C y A a ? O H H B A A B T H T H X C H io A s i 1 9 9 5 r o A a . O B p a u t a A a c b k c y A H C n o A H H T B A i o p a n n a p - c y A a , O A H a K O n o A o x e n n e h b H a M B H H A O C b . 3 . m A S K O B A . r.SaAOHCK. PasMep 3aA0A>KeHH0CTH no aAHMGHxaM, BunAasHBaeMbiM Ha HecoBepnjeHHOAexHHx AGiePi, onpeAGAaeica cyAe6HWM HcnoAHH- leAGM HCXOAa H3 pasMepa aAHMeHXOB, yKaaaHHoro N pemeHHH cyAa H paccHHxaHHoro h 3 3apa6oTxa ! ^ h h h o x o ^ o x o ^ N AHua, obasaHHoro ynAasHBaib aAHMeHXbi, 3 a nepnoA , N TeneHne k o t o - po ro B3blCKaHHe aAHMeHXOB He npOH3BOAHAOCb. B CAyaae, ecAH Bam Myxc N a x o r nepnoA He pa 6 oraA h Hex AOKyMeHTOB, mm iBepiKAaramux e ro 3apa6oroK , aaAOAXceHHOCib no aAHMGHxaM oyAe r paccHHTbiBaxbca nexoAa h 3 paaMepa cpeA - Heii aapaOoxHOH nAaxbi N P # K K !! K k o h cJJeAepauHH ! N MOMeHt B3bicKaHHa 3aA0A)KeHH0CTH (n. 4 cx. 113 CeMeHHoro KOAGKca). E K ^ ! Hex aapaOoxKa ! ^ h h h o x o AoxoAa, na Koxopoe o 6 pamaexca B3biCKaHHe 3aA0A>KeHHOcxH, BaxoMCAyaae, co ra a cH on . 1 cx. 112 CeMeHHoro xoASKCa, B3bicxaHHe npoH3BOAHXca h 3 ASHexHux cpeACXB, HaxoAamnxca na cnexax N 6 aHKax AHua, o6a3aHHoro ynAaMHBaxb aAHMeHXbi. E K ^ h )xe Hex h 3 x h x cpeACXB, BabicxaHHe o 6 pamaexca na Aio 6 oe HMymecxBO AHua, o6H3aHHoro ynAasHBaxb aAHMeHXbi. KOHXpOAb 3a CBOeBpeMGHHblM H npaBHAbHbIM HCnOAHeHHGM pemeHHB cyAa ocymecxBAaex HapeyAba. riosxoM y , & K ^ h N w h g coxAacHbi c m h K x N h ^ m h cyAHcnoAHHXGAa, TO HMeexe npaeo, co - rnacHO cx. 428 TPIK PCcfcCP, oOxcaAOBaxb h onpoxeexoBaxb e ro AeHCXBHB. X aA o 6 bi H npoxecxbi Ha Aencxena cyAeOnoro HcnoAHHxeAa paccMaxpHBaraxca cyAben N cyAe 6 H 0 M aaceAaHHH.